SB 275 – Motion to reconsider action on HFA Zukoff RCS# 597

Judicial

A well-functioning judiciary ensures that every citizen receives equal justice under the law. Sadly, our current judicial system fails at this due to a lack of sufficient conclusiveness in appellate review. West Virginians deserve a compete justice system that is predictable, fair, and conclusive. Despite well-meaning but ultimately ineffective rule changes made by the State Supreme Court in an attempt ensure equal justice for individuals, that fact remains that many rulings by that body are truncated to the point of inadequacy. The lack of signed opinions within the State Supreme Court deprives our citizens of truly equal justice because these opinions do not have authoritative precedential value. This status quo does not achieve the ultimate ends of our judicial system. The right of appeal is meaningless without the assurance of adequately robust decisions. Further, in recent years, it has become apparent that the highly centralized nature of West Virginia’s judicial system has put our state and its citizens at a disadvantage. Anecdotal examples show us circuit courts operating as activists rather than unbiased jurors in a system where our citizens’ court cases never reach a conclusive end. Poor decisions are made by lower courts inside the context that those rulings may never be given a fair amount of scrutiny. The impeachment of our previous State Supreme Court due to that court’s abuses of taxpayer dollars provides unequivocal evidence that the legislature has a compelling interest in instituting improved checks and balances within the judicial branch. An intermediate appellate court—as outlined in our state’s constitution—would provide much needed checks and balances on the status quo.This new appellate court will alleviate these concerns by providing much needed accountability and balance within our judicial branch of government.

AFP POSITION: Support

House District:

27

DELEGATE

John Shott

House District:

29

House District:

3

House District:

49

DELEGATE

Amy Summers

House District:

52

DELEGATE

Terri Sypolt

House District:

48

DELEGATE

Terry Waxman

House District:

12

House District:

60

House District:

18

DELEGATE

Evan Worrell

House District:

22

DELEGATE

Zack Maynard

House District:

35

DELEGATE

Eric Nelson

House District:

28

DELEGATE

Jeffrey Pack

House District:

47

House District:

48

DELEGATE

Ben Queen

House District:

57

DELEGATE

Ruth Rowan

House District:

13

House District:

41

DELEGATE

Jordan Hill

House District:

54

House District:

64

House District:

56

DELEGATE

Gary Howell

House District:

40

House District:

22

DELEGATE

Joe Jeffries

House District:

53

House District:

6

DELEGATE

David Kelly

House District:

32

House District:

16

House District:

9

DELEGATE

Chuck Little

House District:

16

DELEGATE

John Mandt

House District:

58

DELEGATE

Daryl Cowles

House District:

10

DELEGATE

Vernon Criss

House District:

27

House District:

66

House District:

15

DELEGATE

Geoff Foster

House District:

38

House District:

48

House District:

44

DELEGATE

Caleb Hanna

House District:

33

House District:

63

DELEGATE

John Hardy

House District:

11

House District:

10

DELEGATE

Tom Azinger

House District:

7

House District:

39

House District:

62

DELEGATE

Tom Bibby

House District:

35

DELEGATE

Moore Capito

House District:

28

DELEGATE

Roy Cooper

House District:

35

DELEGATE

Doug Skaff

House District:

55

House District:

32

House District:

1

House District:

43

House District:

19

House District:

24

DELEGATE

Tim Tomblin

House District:

31

DELEGATE

Chris Toney

House District:

51

House District:

51

House District:

4

DELEGATE

Lisa Zukoff

House District:

46

House District:

45

DELEGATE

Carl Martin

House District:

1

DELEGATE

Pat McGeehan

House District:

48

DELEGATE

Tim Miley

House District:

23

House District:

25

DELEGATE

Tony Paynter

House District:

5

House District:

27

House District:

37

DELEGATE

Mike Pushkin

House District:

51

DELEGATE

Rodney Pyles

House District:

36

House District:

24

House District:

17

House District:

36

DELEGATE

Larry Rowe

House District:

19

House District:

16

House District:

10

DELEGATE

John Kelly

House District:

42

House District:

50

House District:

17

DELEGATE

Chad Lovejoy

House District:

21

DELEGATE

Mark Dean

House District:

2

House District:

67

DELEGATE

John Doyle

House District:

36

House District:

26

DELEGATE

Ed Evans

House District:

32

DELEGATE

Tom Fast

House District:

51

House District:

3

House District:

51

DELEGATE

Evan Hansen

House District:

43

House District:

8

House District:

50

House District:

61

House District:

30

DELEGATE

Mick Bates

House District:

34

DELEGATE

Brent Boggs

House District:

20

DELEGATE

Nathan Brown

House District:

65

DELEGATE

Sammi Brown

House District:

14

DELEGATE

Jim Butler

House District:

35

DELEGATE

Andrew Byrd

House District:

13

DELEGATE

Scott Cadle

House District:

42

House District:

4

House District:

50

DELEGATE

Mike Caputo

House District:

59

DELEGATE

Larry Kump

Get Vote Alerts